Braća Karamazovi has ratings and reviews. Michelle said: “The Brothers Karamazov” has intrigued me for years. I have always been aware of t. F.M. Dostoyevsky: The Brothers Karamazov, photo by Željko Tutnjević. Home/ / F.M. Dostojevski: Braća Karamazovi, fotografirao Željko Tutnjević. Download. Buy Braca Karamazovi: Ruski Klasici (Hrvatske Knjige) by Fjodor Mihailovic Dostojevski (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low.
|Published (Last):||8 August 2014|
|PDF File Size:||4.14 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||3.6 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
This was the main reason as far as I could understand why Smerdyakov devoted his intellect to petty issues, like manipulating others etc to achieve what he wanted He dreamed of moving to France.
Ora parliamo brevemente del libro.
Braća Karamazovi by Fyodor Dostoyevsky (3 star ratings)
So now I have begun Brothers Karamazov and this is really a disappointment. Yes, yes, I know. Knjiga je bas onakva kakvu sam trazio! He changes his mind after a severe illness, and his materialistic belief is replaced by intense spiritual curiosity; Alyosha is an idealist, lovable and loving. I found pages of extraordinary depth and poignancy but they are few and far in between.
So in a way, I suppose we should admire Dostoyevsky for staying “with it” all the way to the end of his career, unlike all those thousands of now forgotten writers who peaked at middle age and were never relevant again; and for sure this is a smart, beautiful, insightful novel, full of all kinds of things to mentally chew on for those looking to do so. Probably 2 star worthy? I think my next one will be The Possessed https: Thanks for telling us about the problem. Dostoyevsky the man, was a great example of the tortured writer, do you have to have a terrible life to be a good writer?
The next bit happens over a period of a couple of months waiting for the trial.
Braća Karamazovi (The Brothers Karamazov #1-2)
View all 7 bdaca. I find it hard to connect with any of the characters since their personalities are diluted by the manic and morbidly intense verbal flow.
Of course the glorification of suffering does not always have anything to do with spiritual aims, but either way I don’t think it’s worth glorifying please read my review of ‘Confessions’ by Augustine for elaboration why.
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. I did enjoy this book and found it very relevant still today. Alyosha, whom Dostoyevsky declares unambiguously is his hero, is a monk who is sent out in the world by his karamazkvi. Also I’m impressed that he has 18, followers, maybe we’ll see a new book or some e-mails from him soon ; I also like the comparison to the old TV series Dallas as made by one of my book group.
I will kill that old bastard!!! This is a philosophical novel, not packed with a lot of action. Dostoyevsky can write and became so very wise, but at 60 his religious beliefs were much stronger than mine. Check out how the stories – Ilyusha and Dmitri, Katya and Grushenka – intertwine. Dostoyevsky graduated as a military engineer, but resigned in to devote himself to writing.
F.M. Dostojevski: Braća Karamazovi, fotografirao Željko Tutnjević | Dubrovnik Summer Festival
Again, I will not say that despite my criticism of his technique and other things, that this book has been tortuous. His situation was made even worse by his gambling addiction.
Critique One can get off the book easily as first half of the novel is spent in creating the whole plotits hell lot of time to consume a reader. Fatherhood – Fyodor Pavlovich is a bad man and a terrible father. Ivan visits Smerdyakov again, Smerdyakov shows him the missing 3, roubles, is he the real killer? One person found this helpful. Ideas have failed to solve the enigmas of the worldeither we like it or not we are bound by faith. Doubt is actually caricatured at different parts as being one with murderousness Smerdyakovdrunkenness, confusion and violence Dmitri and mental breakdowns Ivan amongst others.
This shows very clearly in the multitude of themes tackled: The first problem is when a speech is so long that it reminds you of Atlas Shrugged. Katerina Ivanovna had a little depth, but Grushenka seemed one-dimensional.
Some depictions like Mrs. Ivan, the intellectual, doesn’t have much of a role to play, but he seems never to be happy. Answers at end of review Okay, I almost never had a good time reading this book. The extended trial scene and I karamazlvi mean eeeeeexxxxxxttttteeeeeeennnnnddddddeeeeeeeeddddd about killed me. Karamzzovi really found this to be a spiritual discussion focusing on faith, morals, crime and class.
Ivan, the This was my second time reading this novel. I would like to read this book again one day, but because of its massive length that day is far off in the future. View all 15 comments. And besides, this book set the precedent that eventually gave us Graca Shruggedand shouldn’t we dislike it a bit just for that alone?
Sounds familiar I just read Maslow. View all 6 comments. He spends time running around trying to raise ready cash from various folks, his ex-fiance’s mother, Samasov, who tries to lead him astray and a drunken lumber merchant. But the energy behind it is more or less insane.
I have to admit I don’t get why this one gets such rave reviews, I did enjoy it once I had battled my way through to the good parts.